Raghuram Rajan’s balancing act of (im)possible trinity

When Raghuram Rajan took over the charge of the governorship of Reserve Bank of India (RBI), India was facing multiple issues. Because of Federal Reserve bond buying tapering speculation (at that time) hot money started flowing out of the emerging countries and India was no different. In addition to that India's unsustainable current account deficit (CAD) fuelled the bearish sentiment of the Rupee. It was the worst performer among the emerging countries currencies.

Meanwhile, then governor D. Subbarao hiked Marginal Standing Facility (MSF) by 200 basis points to prevent the currency outflow and so called excessive speculation. MSF is the rate at which banks borrow from the RBI in times of tight liquidity and it used to be 100 basis points above repo rate. Markets started speculating about RBI’s next possible move of capital controls, which Finance Minister and RBI governor denied repetitively.

Furthermore, India’s growth rate was (is) at its lowest pace in a decade. Inflation dilemma was continuing due to divergence between high level of CPI and moderate levels of WPI. Everybody was contemplating new governor’s stance on monetary policy at this crucial state of the economy.

Governor Rajan was supposed to prevent free fall of rupee, manage market expectation of not pursuing capital controls and have a monetary policy which is independent of all this. Which is impossible trinity and as name suggest it’s practically impossible to achieve all three at the same time.

In his first monetary policy meeting he took two important decisions.

1. Increasing repo rate by 25 basis points and decreasing MSF rates by 75 points. By doing this he took first step towards managing market expectations of not pursuing capital controls and at the same time he stressed upon the anchoring inflation and inflation expectations. By taking these steps he walked towards achieving two legs of the impossible trinity, i.e. free capital movement and independent monetary policy.

2. Providing the Dollar-Rupee swap facility for dollar funded deposits which helped India to attract nearly $12 billion in less than two months from then. This took care of Indian rupee depreciation and rupee recovered from its lowest levels. Third leg of the impossible trinity talks about fixed exchange rate, in which India doesn’t operate as Indian currency is partially pegged one.

Meanwhile, other factors like tapering postponement and Central government's efforts to curtail CAD also helped the market sentiments.

But credit must be given to governor Rajan as he is doing tricky job of balancing the impossible trinity of free capital flows, exchange rate (managed, not fixed in this case) and independent monetary policy, which is anchoring inflation.

Raghuram Rajan: Governorship is not meant to win votes or Facebook “likes”!

Yesterday, 4^th September, Raghuram Rajan took the charge of Reserve Bank of India (RBI) governor’s role from outgoing D. Subbarao.  He started his first day with a bang, effectively communicating his priorities, by this he has taken care of recent criticism faced by RBI of not communicating clearly!

To begin with, he acknowledges the fact that “the economy faces challenges” and “these are not easy times” and at the same time he tried to calm the nerves by saying “India is a fundamentally sound economy with a bright future”.

Never say “Never”!

Rajan said “A central bank should never say “Never”!” meaning RBI is ready to take all possible options available on the table. Also he made it clear that RBI should emphasise on “transparency and predictability”. In these volatility times he wants “RBI should be a beacon of stability as to its objectives” so that markets should know what central banker is doing where it is going.

Monetary Policy

As reported earlier, RBI postponed previously set meeting on 18^th September to 20^th September. Rajan said he postponed it to “have enough time to consider all major developments in the required detail”,  indirectly he is saying he wants to take calculated move after watching policy guidance from United States Federal Reserve meeting scheduled on September 17-18.

He talked about “monetary stability” (different from “price stability”) to emphasize confidence in the Rupee. This is a welcome change in the RBI’s usual language of “price stability” and also “monetary stability” takes care of value of currency, inflation and source of inflation.

Inclusive Development

Rajan said “the RBI will shortly issue the necessary circular to completely free bank branching for domestic scheduled commercial banks in every part of the country. No longer will a well-run scheduled domestic commercial bank have to approach the RBI for permission to open a branch” to give importance to rural banking and small and medium scale industries’ funding.

He said Dr. Bimal Jalan will head a committee to screen the licence applications for new banking licences and hope to announce the licences within, or soon after January 2014. Further he said going ahead RBI will simplify the process of banking licences and banking domain entry.

He stressed about reduction of banks investment in government securities in a calibrated way, which will improve banks productivity and competitiveness.

He talked about foreign banks and their expansion plans but with certain regulations, so that RBI is not blindsided by international developments.

Financial Markets

Rajan talked about liberalising financial markets and restrictions on investment and position taking. So that investors take positions domestically and provide depth and profits to our economy than they take our markets to foreign shores.

He talked about increasing the permitted value of re-booking of cancelled forward exchange contracts for exporters and importers, developing domestic money markets and government securities and introducing interest rate futures on overnight interest rates.

Rupee internationalization and Capital Inflows

In Rajan’s words, “this might be a strange time to talk about rupee internationalization, but we have to think beyond the next few months. As our trade expands, we will push for more settlement in rupees. This will also mean that we will have to open up our financial markets more for those who receive rupees to invest it back in. We intend to continue the path of steady liberalisation. The RBI wants to help our banks bring in safe money to fund our current account deficit”.

Financial Infrastructure

To improve the reach, speed of flows as well as quality and quantity of lending he said strong financial infrastructure is need of the hour. He talked about using Adhaar, and information sharing between credit bureaus and rating agencies.

He talked about the cleaning up of banks balance sheets, bad loan problems and capital raising programs, which might face difficulties in a decelerating growth rate. He pressed for recovering loans, improving of the recovery system and related institutions.

Households

He announced Inflation Indexed Savings Certificates linked to the CPI New Index, to protect the households against CPI inflation. He said electronic bill payment system through bank accounts to “make payments anywhere anytime a reality” and mobile based payment, which can be a revolution if implemented successfully. RBI will facilitate for mini ATMs by non-bank entities.

In conclusion he said, “It involves considerable change, and change is risky. But as India develops, not changing is even riskier. Some of the actions I take will not be popular. The Governorship of the Central Bank is not meant to win one votes or Facebook “likes”. But I hope to do the right thing, no matter what the criticism, even while looking to learn from the criticism”.

Indian equity markets and rupee welcomed Rajan with a rally and brokerages have increased their target levels. Rajan started with a bang, but walking the talk is important now and his path (read my earlier post: Raghuram Rajan’s Trilemma) is not easy.