Will Fed’s QE taper talk topple Rupee again?

When U.S. Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke spoke of reducing bond buying quantity (Presently Fed is buying $85 billion per month and the program is popularly known as QE, quantitative easing) first time in the month of May, markets were surprised and spooked.

U.S. Benchmark 10 year treasury yields jumped more than 100 basis points within a short duration, equity markets throughout the globe slumped, hot money from emerging markets started flowing out, developing countries’ currencies tanked and Indian Rupee was the worst performer of the league. Rupee touched historical all time low of about 69 per dollar in August from as high as 53 per dollar in May.

After continuous speculation in the markets, markets were prepared for QE tapering in September, but Fed took a cautious call not to taper and surprised markets again.

Following 2 successive months of Non Farm Payrolls jobs data around/above 200,000 and unemployment rate falling to 7%, there is again speculation of tapering in the markets. Timing and quantity of the tapering is a debatable question but will that talk of tapering cause volatility in forex markets again? Will Rupee again tank to such drastic level with such aggressive bearish bets.

I think, pace and level of volatility what we saw after Chairman Bernanke comments in May were too fast and too much and that may not repeat if tapering happens also. Obviously there will be some reversal in recent gains attained by Rupee as whenever U.S. sneezes rest of the world catches cold! So there may be slide in the level of Rupee but with not such aggressive pace and the level, seen earlier because of the following five reasons.

Priced in the market

Tapering news was new when Chairman Bernanke spoke about it in the month of May. After that various regional-Fed presidents either talked against it or in support of it. Markets participants started analysing for and against the tapering. Markets were prepared for tapering in September month’s Federal Reserve meeting itself. So this time whenever it happens or mere talk of tapering may not cause such drastic moves in Rupee markets as it is already priced in the markets that eventually tapering had to be done, it’s just a matter of time and quantity.

Bond yields

When Bernanke talked about it first time in May, Benchmark 10 year treasury yields were as low as 1.6% and now they are trading at 2.8%. Talking about Indian government 10 year bond yields, they were around 7.5% in May and now trading at around 9%. Both the countries yields are elevated levels indicating tighter liquidity scenario in coming months and looks like they are prepared for tapering.

Current account

Indian current account deficit (CAD), the difference between outflow and inflow of foreign exchange, was one of the worst among the emerging countries. But CAD reduced substantially over the last quarter. India's current account deficit narrowed sharply to $5.2 billion, or 1.2% of GDP, in the July-September quarter of 2013-14 on the back of turnaround in exports and decline in gold imports. Thanks to RBI and governments moves to curb the gold imports and improvement in exports helped by Rupee depreciation as well as recovery in global economy. The current account deficit was USD 21 billion, or 5 per cent of the GDP, in the second quarter of last fiscal. On Sequential basis also CAD improved from $26.9 billion in previous quarter.

Bottoming out of growth rate

India’s gross domestic production growth rate on decline from 2010 peak and it seems that it is bottoming out around 4.5% - 5% levels. GDP expanded 4.8% in the three months ended 30 September, compared with 4.4% in the preceding quarter. From last 4 quarters Indian GDP is hovering around 4.675% (4.8%, 4.4%, 4.8% 4.7% in reverse order) indicating the bottoming out of the Indian GDP growth rate.

Rajan effect

After Raghuram Rajan became RBI governor, markets showed confidence in his ability and credibility to curb the inflation, bond market reforms, clear communication with market participants and forward guidance. His strategy to attract Dollar deposits through FCNR route helped Rupee to regain some of the losses in the forex market. His shifting focus towards CPI inflation from WPI inflation is good for Indian economy in longer run, even though it may hurt in immediate future. After yesterday’s CPI inflation of around 11%, Rajan may increase repo rate by another 25 basis points in next week’s meeting, which indeed in turn helps Rupee as hot money will be chasing for high yields.

Micro-decoupling factors in a macro-coupling world

During early part of the recent financial crisis, decoupling concept started popping out in financial markets, that certain part of the world is not dependent on the rest of the world. But as crisis deepened, people started realising that in the present globalised world, it’s very difficult say that we are no longer dependent on others!

But there are certain factors, which are very micro, country specifics and are decoupled in macro-coupling economic world. To begin with end, I am still saying global world is a coupled one and no country or state can say that they are fully immune from the rest of the world. Nobody can say that, they are growing only because of domestic reasons.

But below mentioned micro economic factors, which are country specific, are giving signals that they are decoupled in nature in short to medium term.

Inflation

As all of us know inflation, change in the price levels of essential goods and services in a country, plays important role in the country’s economic policy making. I am not such a big fan of Milton Friedman’s proposal of inflation: Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon.

I think inflation can also be because of fiscal expansion, like government spending more but without actually increasing output of the country, leading to bigger amount of money chasing same goods and services, which in turn creating demand-supply mismatch in an economy. Also there can be various other causes like, monetary policy cycle, demographics of the country, savings and expenditure pattern and currency fluctuation.

Keeping aside these causes, Inflation in countries like India, Indonesia and Venezuela is beyond central bankers’ comfort zones whereas in certain parts like Japan, Euro-zone and U.S. it is much below their central bankers’ targeted levels. These developed countries' central bankers are trying pump up the inflation or trying to avoid the deflation whereas developing countries central bankers are trying to minimise the inflation and inflation expectations. Reasons for both the cases vary from country to country, but in above mentioned each part, central bankers are struggling to anchor the inflation in different directions! 

Interest rates

Central bankers of each country (or zone) will be having different mandate/s like growth and/or inflation or only price (inflation) stability or currency stability. Depending on these mandates central bankers decide their course of action in deciding the interest rates and also cycle (upward or downward trend).

Now without getting into each central banker’s mandate, it is easy to say from currently available picture that each country’s interest rate is decoupled from rest of the world. For example India, Brazil, Indonesia are following contractionary monetary policy whereas U.S., Euro-zone, Japan are following ultra-expansionary monetary policy because of the issues these countries (zones) facing are different for different parts of the world.

Current account

In layman terminology, current account is nothing but difference between imports and exports. Depending on the difference between exports and imports, countries will be bifurcated as current account surplus and deficit countries. I believe global trade is a zero-sum as ones loss is others gain, so always there will be current account surplus and deficit countries as long as trade is global and liberal.

Countries like Germany, China and Saudi Arabia are current account surplus ones whereas U.S.,  India and peripheral countries of Euro-zone likes of Greece, Portugal and Spain are current account deficit ones.

Reasons may vary from efficient productivity, economies of scale, natural resources and others but countries are clearly decoupled in this context way above margin!

Equity markets

I would like to cast equity markets in a coupled-macroeconomic section as free capital (hot money) flow in a globalised world is not a country specific phenomenon. Easy money strategy followed by developed world like QE (1, 2, 3 and operation twist) of U.S., low interest rates and LTROs from Euro-zone, Abenomics in Japan is not only pumping their domestic equity markets to new (or regaining historical) levels, but also other countries’ equity markets are also trading at record levels.

Dow Jones and S&P 500 (@highest levels), NASDAQ (@13 year high) of U.S. and Dax of Germany are trading at historical levels. Japan’s Nikkei 225 is at almost 6 years high, India’s Nifty and Sensex are trading either highest level or around historical high levels.